![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Title: Incurable (The "All You Zombies" Remix)
Author:
alixtii
Summary: She knows there is only one person who can find, and save, her.
Fandom: Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Firefly/Harry Potter
Pairings: Minerva McGonagall/Rupert Giles/River Tam, Winifred Burkle/Kaywinnit Lee Frye
Rating: PG
Disclaimer: Joss' and Jo's, not mine
Original story: Incurable by Ari
* * *
Incurable (The "All You Zombies" Remix)
"You lost her." It's not a question when Lilah says it.
Of course they wouldn't be able to find you, you think. They could not help but to lose you, with their hands of blue, two by two; you were hidden so well, so deeply that it would be a challenge even for you to find yourself.
"There were complications," they say. "The Parliament authorized a--"
"I didn't ask for your excuses." They shut up. Lilah turns her back on them, looks at you, her gaze unrelenting in its penetration. "I don't suppose I need to stress how important our target is to the interests of the firm, under the circumstances."
"No, ma'am," you say.
You're nearby, you know. You can sense your own presence, and it's suddenly difficult to separate your thoughts from, well, your own. It's hard enough to keep a rein on the insanity which still rages, sometimes, in the back of your brain, but now here it is again, and out of control, engulfing, fashioning its own world which consumes you and threatens to consume you as well. You wish you could teach yourself how to control yourself. You will in time, you know, but not yet. Not until later. Or before.
Not to mention all the other mad thoughts which threaten to pierce your shields, the twisted and perverted realities of not only Potter and Summers but all the other poor architects of the multiverse as well: Wormwood, Mars, Craig, Kincaid, plus others whose names you never managed to learn. It is maddeningly impossible to keep your focus (your focii, really, under the circumstances), and so you key in on the closest mind whose thoughts could almost be seen as half-sane: the night watchman.
Holmer's mind is an impressive edifice of doublethink--it is, of course, the only thing that keeps him sane--at least in comparison to those he watches.
His thoughts are mundane, of his flat and of his telly; they have to be, really. He is at the moment the only one aware of the brick and of the rock which provides a house to the asylum; without him to anchor them all in this place they'd all drift apart forever, their realities to never touch or merge again. He is the only one who can do it; you cannot be trusted to, not today.
You look deeper. There it is: the memory of a man in twenty-first century garb and a woman in robes, already willed to be forgotten. Rupert, of course, with Minerva. Buried even deeper is the door through which they came, a door which isn't when all the rest of St. Bruno's is. He must forget, but you can't afford to.
Holmer took them to the director, of course, who will take them to you. And you will find them, and you will--no. It's too early. Or is it? You can't remember. Are the memories in front of you or behind you? You can't tell anymore.
Which is the real you? You laugh at the question. Would the other be the fake you? Absurd.
"Are any of the residents truly mad?" Rupert asks you.
"Course they are," you answer. "I am. The Summers girl was."
This gets a reaction from Rupert, and an internal laugh from Minerva. "Buffy wasn't mad," Rupert argues. "She really was the Slayer."
But of course Buffy was the Slayer. And Harry really was a wizard. Matilda's a telekinetic, Veronica's in love with her father, Max is genetically engineered, Claudia Jean will really grow up to be the 46th President of the United States of America, et cetera. What does Rupert think the world is made out of? All those bits and molecules no one's ever seen?
Of course not. You know enough to trust eyes and heart alone. Life is a tale told by an idiot--or, more precisely, a madman. Or a madwoman. Dreams and fantasies are the only thing left to live on.
But Minerva understands. "Those two don't necessarily contradict each other, Rupert."
The three of you, Rupert, Minerva, and youtself, apparate away, so you're not there anymore, and as you're ripped away from yourself, the barriers go down as the insanity at last wears away your shields.
Darkness.
"Thank God," Simon says as you open your eyes to Fred's smiling face. "I thought we lost her."
"Nah," says Kaylee, standing next to Fred, holding her hand. Fred's other hand still holds an empty syringe. "Fred's smart. And River's too much of a fighter."
"That she is," Fred agrees cheerfully as she puts down the syringe. Then she pauses, an expression of horror passes over her features, and she spasms.
Simon catches her before she falls, his doctor's instincts kicking in. "What is it?" he asks.
Kaylee just looks at her girlfriend in horror as Fred's eyes, hair, lips change color.
"It's my fault," you say, suddenly understanding. You thought you were home, here on Serenity, but realization hits as you watch. You remember.
"What?" Simon asks, not looking at you, checking the pupils of Fred's newly blue eyes. "Of course it isn't, mei-mei."
But it is. Reality's unraveling, destabilized. You have to fix it before that fearful symmetry is shattered now and forever.
You pick up a full syringe, lying next to where Fred placed the empty one, and plunge it into your chest.
Again, darkness. No, wait: not darkness. Whiteness. You are given unto it.
You're in a white room--if it is a room at all. It might just be whiteness, you're not sure.
Alone in the room is yourself--just the one of you, mercifully--and another woman, younger than you. She wears a button: 73.9% Ravenclaw. You wonder what the other twenty-six percent is.
She looks at you, and if you thought Lilah's gaze was penetrating, this is no comparison. She can see into the very depths of your soul, understands you like no man or woman in your world possibly could. You know this without knowing how you know it. You know it because she wants you to know it.
"You remember now," the woman says, as with certainty. You wonder if it is possible for her, in this room, to tell a lie. Somehow it seems that when she speaks, truth and falsity drop out of the equation. You exist in the space between her words. "Where they took you."
"A chateau," you answer. "In the south of France."
She makes no expression, as if she knew all of this all along. "The universe?" she asks, but you know she already knows the answer.
"Potter's," you answer.
She nods. "You'll go there, of course. You remember what you need to do."
"But . . . why?" You have no more articulate a question than that,
She pauses, smiles a sad smile. "Because you suffer so beautifully, River."
The whiteness consumes you again, and you find yourself in Wolfram & Hart's elevator.
Why the Lassiter? you wonder sometimes. You still don't know, and you suppose you never will. Some things don't need reasons; that's why there are loops. Why the complicated and twisted, beautiful pattern of time and space came to be the way it is is something you doubt you will ever manage to figure out; if anyone at all knows, perhaps it is that girl in that white room atop the elevator.
You take the Lassiter and travel to ago, to the south of France, to the chateau.
Rupert and Minerva will teach you--did teach you--are teaching you--you go through the entire conjugation in your mind and it almost, as a sum, manages to describe the teaching. There is teaching, past, present, and/or future, and the teaching is (you stick to the present tense; every moment is an eternal now) the source of many lessons for you, perhaps the most important lessons of them all, and you will always be very grateful for them.
But there is a time for the teaching to come to the end. It is time to teach yourself what you need to learn now.
The cottage is warded--Albus wouldn't have left Minerva an unwarded cottage--but the wards don't recognize you as a threat. You are what they are set up to protect, after all.
Minerva looks from you to you as you open the door and enter the room. "River?" You're not sure which of you she is speaking to.
"I'm sorry, Minerva," you say and fire the Lassiter once, twice. Both Minerva and Rupert are wizards of a sort, but they are both mortal and unprepared, and they fall, inevitably, to the Lassiter's blasts.
You look at yourself, and you're not afraid--why should you be? You know you're not a threat. You take your hand. "Come, River," you say. You leave the cottage hand in hand, and only one of you looks back.
In so many worlds of fantasy, precious grand illusions come true, in all the dreams dreamt by Harry and by Buffy and by you, there are still some inexorable truths which cannot be escaped, as much as you would like to try.
You've always known that you were the only one who could ever save you from yourself.
Author:
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Summary: She knows there is only one person who can find, and save, her.
Fandom: Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Firefly/Harry Potter
Pairings: Minerva McGonagall/Rupert Giles/River Tam, Winifred Burkle/Kaywinnit Lee Frye
Rating: PG
Disclaimer: Joss' and Jo's, not mine
Original story: Incurable by Ari
* * *
Incurable (The "All You Zombies" Remix)
"You lost her." It's not a question when Lilah says it.
Of course they wouldn't be able to find you, you think. They could not help but to lose you, with their hands of blue, two by two; you were hidden so well, so deeply that it would be a challenge even for you to find yourself.
"There were complications," they say. "The Parliament authorized a--"
"I didn't ask for your excuses." They shut up. Lilah turns her back on them, looks at you, her gaze unrelenting in its penetration. "I don't suppose I need to stress how important our target is to the interests of the firm, under the circumstances."
"No, ma'am," you say.
You're nearby, you know. You can sense your own presence, and it's suddenly difficult to separate your thoughts from, well, your own. It's hard enough to keep a rein on the insanity which still rages, sometimes, in the back of your brain, but now here it is again, and out of control, engulfing, fashioning its own world which consumes you and threatens to consume you as well. You wish you could teach yourself how to control yourself. You will in time, you know, but not yet. Not until later. Or before.
Not to mention all the other mad thoughts which threaten to pierce your shields, the twisted and perverted realities of not only Potter and Summers but all the other poor architects of the multiverse as well: Wormwood, Mars, Craig, Kincaid, plus others whose names you never managed to learn. It is maddeningly impossible to keep your focus (your focii, really, under the circumstances), and so you key in on the closest mind whose thoughts could almost be seen as half-sane: the night watchman.
Holmer's mind is an impressive edifice of doublethink--it is, of course, the only thing that keeps him sane--at least in comparison to those he watches.
His thoughts are mundane, of his flat and of his telly; they have to be, really. He is at the moment the only one aware of the brick and of the rock which provides a house to the asylum; without him to anchor them all in this place they'd all drift apart forever, their realities to never touch or merge again. He is the only one who can do it; you cannot be trusted to, not today.
You look deeper. There it is: the memory of a man in twenty-first century garb and a woman in robes, already willed to be forgotten. Rupert, of course, with Minerva. Buried even deeper is the door through which they came, a door which isn't when all the rest of St. Bruno's is. He must forget, but you can't afford to.
Holmer took them to the director, of course, who will take them to you. And you will find them, and you will--no. It's too early. Or is it? You can't remember. Are the memories in front of you or behind you? You can't tell anymore.
Which is the real you? You laugh at the question. Would the other be the fake you? Absurd.
"Are any of the residents truly mad?" Rupert asks you.
"Course they are," you answer. "I am. The Summers girl was."
This gets a reaction from Rupert, and an internal laugh from Minerva. "Buffy wasn't mad," Rupert argues. "She really was the Slayer."
But of course Buffy was the Slayer. And Harry really was a wizard. Matilda's a telekinetic, Veronica's in love with her father, Max is genetically engineered, Claudia Jean will really grow up to be the 46th President of the United States of America, et cetera. What does Rupert think the world is made out of? All those bits and molecules no one's ever seen?
Of course not. You know enough to trust eyes and heart alone. Life is a tale told by an idiot--or, more precisely, a madman. Or a madwoman. Dreams and fantasies are the only thing left to live on.
But Minerva understands. "Those two don't necessarily contradict each other, Rupert."
The three of you, Rupert, Minerva, and youtself, apparate away, so you're not there anymore, and as you're ripped away from yourself, the barriers go down as the insanity at last wears away your shields.
Darkness.
"Thank God," Simon says as you open your eyes to Fred's smiling face. "I thought we lost her."
"Nah," says Kaylee, standing next to Fred, holding her hand. Fred's other hand still holds an empty syringe. "Fred's smart. And River's too much of a fighter."
"That she is," Fred agrees cheerfully as she puts down the syringe. Then she pauses, an expression of horror passes over her features, and she spasms.
Simon catches her before she falls, his doctor's instincts kicking in. "What is it?" he asks.
Kaylee just looks at her girlfriend in horror as Fred's eyes, hair, lips change color.
"It's my fault," you say, suddenly understanding. You thought you were home, here on Serenity, but realization hits as you watch. You remember.
"What?" Simon asks, not looking at you, checking the pupils of Fred's newly blue eyes. "Of course it isn't, mei-mei."
But it is. Reality's unraveling, destabilized. You have to fix it before that fearful symmetry is shattered now and forever.
You pick up a full syringe, lying next to where Fred placed the empty one, and plunge it into your chest.
Again, darkness. No, wait: not darkness. Whiteness. You are given unto it.
You're in a white room--if it is a room at all. It might just be whiteness, you're not sure.
Alone in the room is yourself--just the one of you, mercifully--and another woman, younger than you. She wears a button: 73.9% Ravenclaw. You wonder what the other twenty-six percent is.
She looks at you, and if you thought Lilah's gaze was penetrating, this is no comparison. She can see into the very depths of your soul, understands you like no man or woman in your world possibly could. You know this without knowing how you know it. You know it because she wants you to know it.
"You remember now," the woman says, as with certainty. You wonder if it is possible for her, in this room, to tell a lie. Somehow it seems that when she speaks, truth and falsity drop out of the equation. You exist in the space between her words. "Where they took you."
"A chateau," you answer. "In the south of France."
She makes no expression, as if she knew all of this all along. "The universe?" she asks, but you know she already knows the answer.
"Potter's," you answer.
She nods. "You'll go there, of course. You remember what you need to do."
"But . . . why?" You have no more articulate a question than that,
She pauses, smiles a sad smile. "Because you suffer so beautifully, River."
The whiteness consumes you again, and you find yourself in Wolfram & Hart's elevator.
Why the Lassiter? you wonder sometimes. You still don't know, and you suppose you never will. Some things don't need reasons; that's why there are loops. Why the complicated and twisted, beautiful pattern of time and space came to be the way it is is something you doubt you will ever manage to figure out; if anyone at all knows, perhaps it is that girl in that white room atop the elevator.
You take the Lassiter and travel to ago, to the south of France, to the chateau.
Rupert and Minerva will teach you--did teach you--are teaching you--you go through the entire conjugation in your mind and it almost, as a sum, manages to describe the teaching. There is teaching, past, present, and/or future, and the teaching is (you stick to the present tense; every moment is an eternal now) the source of many lessons for you, perhaps the most important lessons of them all, and you will always be very grateful for them.
But there is a time for the teaching to come to the end. It is time to teach yourself what you need to learn now.
The cottage is warded--Albus wouldn't have left Minerva an unwarded cottage--but the wards don't recognize you as a threat. You are what they are set up to protect, after all.
Minerva looks from you to you as you open the door and enter the room. "River?" You're not sure which of you she is speaking to.
"I'm sorry, Minerva," you say and fire the Lassiter once, twice. Both Minerva and Rupert are wizards of a sort, but they are both mortal and unprepared, and they fall, inevitably, to the Lassiter's blasts.
You look at yourself, and you're not afraid--why should you be? You know you're not a threat. You take your hand. "Come, River," you say. You leave the cottage hand in hand, and only one of you looks back.
In so many worlds of fantasy, precious grand illusions come true, in all the dreams dreamt by Harry and by Buffy and by you, there are still some inexorable truths which cannot be escaped, as much as you would like to try.
You've always known that you were the only one who could ever save you from yourself.
(no subject)
Date: 2007-04-22 04:27 pm (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2007-04-23 02:49 am (UTC)(no subject)
Date: 2007-04-23 05:23 am (UTC)Ze really does, doesn't ze? *g*
(no subject)
Date: 2007-04-29 06:51 pm (UTC)I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [1]
Date: 2007-04-23 05:20 am (UTC)The Lilah/River reminds me of Elizabeth's fic Tell Me What My Hands Were Made For, partially because we were just talking about it last night, but there's the whole Wolfram+Hart in the future thing. I'm also reminded forcably of "School of Lost Souls" for similar reasons. I like W+H in the Firefly 'verse because it fits so well and connects the two universi.
Also, subtle Lilah/River subtext, like "her gaze unrelenting in its penetration." :p
So, I really love where you've gone with architects of the multiverse and how you literally expanded this in the obvious direction I was going. I think I caught all the refs except I don't know who "Kincaid" is. But, seriously, I love how they're actually creating their worlds, how they're actually more powerful than less, and how that plays into the central issues of creativity and writing that manifest in the meta bit.
Holmer's mind is an impressive edifice of doublethink
It really is, isn't it? I'd almost forgotten there was an OC in this.
He is at the moment the only one aware of the brick and of the rock which provides a house to the asylum; without him to anchor them all in this place they'd all drift apart forever, their realities to never touch or merge again.
And the beautiful literalizing of the postmodern moment in which our realities only exist because we construct them.
I'm also really interested in the way you've reinvested all the superheroes with this kind of power, especially River, with agency, which now that I think about it is obvious (one of these things is will-to-powery, one of these things is putting certain characters in helpless situations and then making adults frell them), but has definitely made me think about the way that I not-even-intentionally locate my kink.
Which is the real you? You laugh at the question. Would the other be the fake you? Absurd.
I love this line and can't quite say why.
Matilda's a telekinetic, Veronica's in love with her father, Max is genetically engineered, Claudia Jean will really grow up to be the 46th President of the United States of America, et cetera.
I have to say, one of my favorite things about this is the addition of Matilda. (I really feel guilty in looking over my version of the story about how I totally made up names and "delusions" for the other residents; yours makes so much more sense in addition to being more satisfying.) The other characters, too, of course, but somehow Matilda's stor(y)(ies) are the ones that are writing themselves in my head. I didn't know you were familiar with Dark Angel; CJ is sex, and I'm very glad Veronica is in love with her father although curious about how her mundane/fantastic worlds play out besides that.
I am not your remix author...
Date: 2007-04-23 06:39 am (UTC)I was thinking Janine, but of course she's a Kishi. And I got mixed up (hah!) with Claudia Kincaid from The Mixed-Up Files of Mrs Basil E Frankweiler...
Or there's Claire Kincaid from L&O.
I got nothin'...
Re: I am not your remix author...
Date: 2007-04-23 07:59 am (UTC)And every time I try to type that name? It comes out Kinkaid. EVERY SINGLE TIME.
Re: I am not your remix author...
Date: 2007-04-23 01:27 pm (UTC)Me neither.
My brain went "Jamaica Kincaid," which is of course useless.
It makes me wince that Claudia Jean's surname is misspelled, though.
-not anon 'cause did not participate in Remix
Re: I am not your remix author...
Date: 2007-04-29 06:48 pm (UTC)Thanks for pointing out the misspelling in C.J.'s name.
Re: I am not your remix author...
Date: 2007-04-29 06:51 pm (UTC)Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-04-28 12:41 am (UTC)It reminds me a bit of Permutations (http://alixtii.livejournal.com/56109.html)
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-04-29 06:55 pm (UTC)Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-04-29 08:49 pm (UTC)One of the side effects of doing the Remix is that you basically stalk a writer, or at least stalk their writing. Given the short window of time in which this is happening, you learn the voice and mannerisms of your remixee.
There were a couple people whom I thought I should have been able to figure out and didn't so it was fun to say, "Hey wait! I recognize this writer!"
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-05-05 11:06 am (UTC)Whereas Ari and I learned to recognize each other's styles the long, drawn out way. She's like one of maybe two or three people, tops, whose writing I can recognize--which is odd because it isn't even as if she has a particular style, per se, more like a range of styles.
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-04-29 05:41 pm (UTC)I'm not sure how I feel about W&H in Firefly--it's not a seamless transition--but it's too darned useful a trope not to use. It's like you once said about the use of Edenic imagery in a Lilah fic: "One day I'm going to come up with a whole new system, but today is not the day."
So, I really love where you've gone with architects of the multiverse and how you literally expanded this in the obvious direction I was going.
Hmm. What one person sees a flaw, another sees as an asset. I love your story for many reasons, but one is that it can't be pinned down. Yes, I "literally expanded" the story in one of the more obvious directions the story was going, but in so doing I opened Schrodiner's box. I don't regret this--after all, the original story still exists in all its multifaceted glory--but one of the things I love about "Incurable" is that a hundred remixes could be written and every one would be unique. It's such a rich, nuanced, and subtle story, where things can't be easily equated and figured out, and I sort of steamrollered over the nuances and subtleties in creating a world that was much more straight-foward. Which, again, not regretting, because it worked for the story I wanted to tell.
I don't remember who Kincaid was supposed to be. I feel like she was supposed to be a BSC reference but if there isn't a character with that name then that can't be the case. I agree that Claudia would fit right in this universe, though.
I've netflixed most of S1 of Dark Angel so far, plus I watched all of the Major Kira episodes during a Sci-Fi marathon.
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-09-19 02:09 am (UTC)Edited to keep "kids" in the subject position of both kinks.
(no subject)
Date: 2012-01-23 02:53 am (UTC)also because I know it will drive you nuts that you have to wait till reveal to discuss [2]
Date: 2007-04-23 05:21 am (UTC)And again the story-telling. I appreciate your thematic worldbuilding so much. And I do appreciate the inclusion of the Fred/Kaylee and of Illyria, since I know both were discussed in the comments of my fic.
73.9% Ravenclaw. You wonder what the other twenty-six percent is.
According to the original poll (more people have voted since a certain percentage was immortalized), Gryff (yeah, I don't know either) and 'Puff (as I'm sure you know, since you voted in it. I mean. I have no idea who wrote this for me), but I love that contextually, Slytherin (in the sense of evil, not ambitious) makes the most sense. Oooh.
You wonder if it is possible for her, in this room, to tell a lie. Somehow it seems that when she speaks, truth and falsity drop out of the equation. You exist in the space between her words.
I love you SO MUCH.
(Although am slightly disturbed that Ari/River seems to be an OTP of yours.)
"Because you suffer so beautifully, River."
<3
And I would not be at all surprised to discover that I've secretly been working for Wolfram and Hart since before "Children of the Gods"*.
I am still unsure about how to respond the end, since my immediate thought is "BUT OT3! No killing of the OT3!" But yes, heartache and twistiness definitely belong in the writer's toolbox. I fully love the time-loops and their rationale, and the intricicy of your construction of the world(s).
I find it curious that in a sense the culmination of this fic is a scene I didn't write, when much of the focus is on a quasi-Ari writing, creating, controlling the 'versi (I'm hesitant about referring to her as me, since clearly she's not since she wrote this world and thus exists between you and the text as internal author, whereas I exist on the other side of you in the following sense:
[Joss 'n' Jo --> sourcetext --> Ari --> "Incurable" --> mystery remixer --> "All You Zombies" fictive author --> actual true events of this story]
I think. Clearly where I need a flowchart to understand the construction of this fic, something is right.
precious grand illusions come true, in all the dreams dreamt by Harry and by Buffy and by you, there are still some inexorable truths which cannot be escaped, as much as you would like to try.
You've always known that you were the only one who could ever save you from yourself.
This is where I really, really appreciate the second-person, especially as I realize this: that I-as-writer had intial ultimate control, and "precious grand illusions" is an excellent name for the massive way in which "Incurable" is wish-fulfillment fic for me and River is my Mary Sue, and then I-as-reader of this fic lost, as readers do, that kind of control over the text, which acts on me (which is a nice reversal of the sense in which River has more agency [though perhaps not more autonomy] in your fic than in mine; River's agency is inverted to mine), but then the text literally invites me to take control again and serves as a personal chastisement (which is in no wise a bad thing) given my very large desire to have people other-than-me save me, or save me from myself.
I really, really loved this; it made me grin the first time through, and in doing a careful read-through to write this comment, I feel I've absorbed more nuances and love it even more. Thank you so much for writing for me.
Typo: The three of you, Rupert, Minerva, and youtself
*"Children of the Gods" is the first episode of Stargate: SG-1. It's possible there exists fanfic in which Jack and Sam have been secretly married since before CotG; it's become a bit of a catchphrase between la girl and me.
(and in the tiny, miniscule chance that you're not the person I think you are, a) I trust you're still either a very adept stalker or a flister and b) sorry?)
Re: also because I know it will drive you nuts that you have to wait till reveal to discuss [2]
Date: 2007-04-29 06:46 pm (UTC)I had completely forgotten that poll, despite having voted in it.
Agreed about you not being, exactly, the woman in the White Room. But then no writer who appears within a work is really the writer of the work itself. My inspiration for the White Room scene was Anna Kovsky's "A Critique of
Pure Reason" in which she speaks to Dom in the White Room as she types on a typewriter, but the real Kovsky is (well, was, really) writing in a notebook while being bored in class. Your eyes can never see themselves--only their reflection, which my remix attempts to provide in a way. (And you can't use a pencil to write a name on itself.)
I really don't think of this fic as either Ari/River or Lilah/River, certainly not the way that "Dear My Ideal Audience" or "The Fairest of Them All" are, although I considered the possibility of going ther Lilah/River route. I decided against it not only because I thought the story screamed that I had written it enough as it was, but also because, oddly enough considering, sexualized relationships seemed strangely out of place within it. I did consider stealing more elements from "Ideal Audience" as well--in particular, the "My God why have you forsaken me?" line--but I decided it against it for a similar manifold of reasons. And of course I've transferred some of the things you've actually said about, I believe, Wesley, over to River.
This is only the second remix I've written, and this one breaks the rules in so many ways, but I think in general the culmination of a remix I've written will be a scene that didn't appear in the original, since I'm telling a completely new narrative based on the same sequence of events. I don't think I'd typically be this far removed from the original--I'd stay in the same universe, typically--but of course "Incurable" draws attention to the radical possibility of what lies beyond itself.
The second person was an element that I knew would in part serve to identify my authorship, since I use it so much, but I couldn't think of a way to tell the story without it. And yes, I love some of the sentences I was able to priduce thanks to the bifurcation of the "you." The "inexorable truths" line was added late in the game, because I thought the language in general wasn't as beautiful enough as behooved an Ari fic.
I realize this: that I-as-writer had intial ultimate control, and "precious grand illusions" is an excellent name for the massive way in which "Incurable" is wish-fulfillment fic for me and River is my Mary Sue, and then I-as-reader of this fic lost, as readers do, that kind of control over the text, which acts on me (which is a nice reversal of the sense in which River has more agency [though perhaps not more autonomy] in your fic than in mine; River's agency is inverted to mine), but then the text literally invites me to take control again and serves as a personal chastisement (which is in no wise a bad thing) given my very large desire to have people other-than-me save me, or save me from myself.
About 2/3 of that is intentional.
Thank you for the wonderful feedback, and I'm glad you enjoyed the remix. Thank you so much for the original stor(y)(ies), for the years of discussion, and for so much more. You've been a blessing to all of us.
(I like to imagine the universe in which this fic was written by a very adept stalker.)
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-04-30 03:24 am (UTC)If I hadn't already guessed you were writing for me from your initial terrified post on receiving your assignment, Kaylee's full name in the header would've given it away, and then the second-person River pov kind of sealed it. So's you know.
I really appreciate you using your deep and true knowledge of me and my worlds to write this for me.
♥
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-05-05 12:51 am (UTC)Victoria explicitly told us to use our characters' full names! I was just following the rules when I used Kaywinnit and Winifred! What else was I supposed to do? (Seriously. I wonder about this every blind exchange I'm in. Well, not so much Yuletide.)
I suppose I should have flocked the terrified post. That might have thrown you off the scent--although not for long, obviously.
I would have been pulling for the v. adept stalker too.
Re: I really only wrote such a long comment so I could use multiple of my highly appropriate icons [
Date: 2007-05-05 01:28 am (UTC)I thought about this for a long time wrt to Faith, since I am, hem, quite strongly opposed to the use of "Lehane," but I saw other people had tagged it thus. I also ended up tagging it as "fandom: angel the series" though its proper name is Angel because I thought the fandom would veer that way. (Which it didn't.)
Re: also because I know it will drive you nuts that you have to wait till reveal to discuss [2]
Date: 2009-10-07 08:42 pm (UTC)That would make a lot of sense, actually.
(Gotta love Hulu.)
Re: also because I know it will drive you nuts that you have to wait till reveal to discuss [2]
Date: 2009-10-07 08:44 pm (UTC)*is kidding*
*mostly*
Re: also because I know it will drive you nuts that you have to wait till reveal to discuss [2]
Date: 2009-10-07 08:53 pm (UTC)The only pairing I don't really get is Sam/Janet--despite loving both characters to pieces, but then I haven't seen "Heroes," in large part because I don't feel up to the emotional drain.
If I have an OTP in the fandom, it's Cassandra and Jack's clone. This probably doesn't surprise you in the least.